There is a lot of friction in the church today over music. So much so that it is a super hot topic on every side of the fence imaginable.
You’ve got what some call “the old people” howling about how we don’t sing hymns anymore.
And you’ve got the young kids saying they can’t relate to the archaic lyrics of hymns and prefer a more “modern worship experience”.
And there are many shades and facets and opinions all the way around the table on this.
Sometimes I’m not sure where I stand on the whole thing. I really enjoy some current music and enjoy when I am able to sing it in church instead of just in the car by myself. But the only problem with this scenario that I’ve come across is…and I am not talking about any church in particular, but this is something I have heard expressed in many places…the only problem is that I seldom know a single song that is being done. So I just stand there. And look around. And watch all the other people just standing there. Not singing, just like me.
So this “corporate worship time” is in actuality a “concert”. But the only thing is, I usually know the words when I go to a concert because I know the artist. At church, I usually end up staring at the screen at lyrics I’ve never seen before…and will most likely never see again. And a part of my soul that wants to sing out to my Creator is stifled.
And the reason I am telling that part is not to rat on anybody, but to make an important point. About hymns.
And before you say “oh boy, there she goes, harping in hymns and hating other music”, hear me out, ok?
Almost any worshipful song has the potential to bring believers into the presence of God..and isn’t that the goal? But one of the things that bothers me about this strange trend to be led in singing a lineup of things no one knows is that there is no continuity there.
I am struggling to explain myself, so it feels like things are getting very wordy and I’m just now getting to my point, so bear with me. I have shared before how we sang two songs at Bub’s memorial. One was a more contemporary song, You Are My All in All (by Dennis Jernigan) and the other was a hymn, Great is Thy Faithfulness. The interesting thing about both of these songs is that God has used both of these songs in many contexts in my life. I have sung the contemporary one during happy times and obviously sad times, and yet the words remain true and become stronger within me the more I sing them. The same is true for the hymn. I have been singing that song my whole life in every possible context…from a ‘nothing’ Sunday as a child or as an adult at a wedding and at a funeral and beyond. And every time I sing the song it takes me to all those places. And reminds me of the past and where I am now and where God has taken me and wants to take me from here and continues to anchor those words to my heart that indeed, God is faithful. Every word and every phrase means more to me now than it did the last time I heard it. And God shows me something new of Himself the next time I sing it that I didn’t know all the other times. And that brings me full circle..not to worship the past, as many people “accuse” older adults of wanting to do…but to a new place, yes connected to the past, but only knowing the now because of it.
I am a poor communicator, but those last sentences are what I’ve been trying to get to. So many times I’ve been in modern worship services and there is no connection to the past or the present in what I’m singing,,,or just listening to. And I miss that gentle knowing that there is no shadow of turning with Thee…all I have needed Thy hand hath provided..Great is Thy Faithfulness, Lord Unto Me. And knowing that I know that. Or whatever lyric that God choses to use to draw me to see more of Him this time in the hearing of the same words than I heard and knew of Him last time I heard those same words. This…THIS is my struggle with the modern way that is constantly in flux..constantly introducing the new and throwing out the old..or the older. We’re missing a gentle jewel that God has for us.
*Please don’t hate me or tell me that I am wrong in this or that I don’t understand or that I am being judgmental or slamming this or that..I am merely sharing my experience and what God has revealed to me through his Spirit.